Measured route shape, not a vibe check.
Measure whether the current public review route is short, current, and non-confusing before it is used as OpenAI-role leverage. Current result: route shape passes, external reviewer proof is still missing.
- Status
- watch
- Route
- ciw-role-review
- Gate
- No outbound before 2026-05-26
What changed
| passRole review stays the first decision surface | 3 decision links, 730 words | The entrypoint stops being a short decision surface. |
|---|---|---|
| passScorecard is rows, not card spam | 10 score rows; old score-card class absent | The scorecard regresses to a decorative card wall. |
| passReviewer digest is compressed | 5 primary route links, 738 words | The digest becomes a proof inventory instead of a route. |
| passSystem map is static, not fake dashboard UI | 7 system rows; old filter/detail controls absent | The company map pretends to be an operating dashboard. |
| passLaunch readiness is a table | 4 readiness rows; old band-card/surface-card classes absent | Launch readiness returns to launch theater. |
| passLegacy digest no longer duplicates the route | refresh=0; url=../ciw-review-digest/; robots=noindex | The old OpenAI-named digest becomes a second current digest again. |
| watchExternal reviewer record is still the missing proof | external_reviewer_feedback=not_collected | The route claims validation before non-Nic feedback exists. |
| passExternal review intake is operational, not only a protocol | status=ready_for_external_reviewer; records=0; fields=present; receiver=present | The route has a protocol but no source-recovery path, launch boundary, or passive issue receiver. |
| passClassified external-review record projection is empty and explicit | record_count=0; records=0 | The route cannot prove whether external reviewer records exist. |
| passRole-review counts mirror ledger summary | records=96; graph_nodes=82 | The role-review entrypoint hardcodes stale receipt or graph counts. |
What this does not prove
- This audit measures route shape only; it is not OpenAI-side outcome evidence.
- No outbound before 2026-05-26 unless a verified real reply or explicit fresh override changes the route.
- No OpenAI affiliation, employment, endorsement, customer, revenue, legal entity, or company-formation claim.
- No private data, email address, raw message text, local absolute path, credential, account data, or customer material in public records.